
I have reposted Fred Claire's MLB.com's baseball column dealing with A-Rod, roids and it's continued impact on the game. I have known Fred for over thirty years from when he first hired me on as the Dodger photographer. We have remained friends ever since and as added value, SuiteCaptures business associates.
His take on the A-Rod dilemma is exceptional but consistent with the man's value system...of which I have learned much from over these years. Regardless of whether or not you're a sports fan, there is a message for us all in the following words:
Dear Alex:
I wanted to write to you because I know this is a confusing and disturbing time for you. I'm sure you are having a number of conversations with your agent, Scott Boras, and with representatives of the MLB Players Association. I hope you also are talking to your family and your most trusted advisors.You are in the center of a storm with the story by Sports Illustrated that you tested positive for the use of two anabolic steroids in 2003.I know everyone in the world, particularly members of the news media, is telling you what you should do and how you should respond to your current crisis. I know my voice is just one more in this swirling parade of opinions, but I did spend 30 years as an executive in Major League Baseball and I have spent a lifetime caring about our great game.
Alex, here is what you face -- the next words you speak about the charges you used steroids will determine your legacy in baseball and, indeed, your life.
I hope you have listened to your agent, your union and all of your trusted friends and advisors. At this time, however, you have control and it is up to you to respond and to set the course for your future. Listen very carefully to what you hear from your own heart and your own soul. This is not a time for a crafted statement from your agent or from the union on your behalf. This is a time for you, Alex, to step forward and take full control. It is your career. It is your life.
Simply stated, you need to step forward and tell everything you recall about your involvement, or lack of involvement, with steroids. I know you have addressed questions on this subject previously. I know that each time, you have denied having used steroids, human growth hormone or any other performance-enhancing substance. The difference is the questions didn't come at a time when you personally have been linked to a positive test. This time you have been linked. This is different.
Sure, it's difficult to come forward and say you haven't been truthful in the past when facing these questions. However, the truth is your best and only true course.
If it sounds like I'm jumping to a conclusion and presuming guilt, I'm not.
If you have never used a performance-enhancing substance, say so and say so in a loud and clear manner. Whatever you do, don't respond in the manner you did last week when approached by a Sports Illustrated reporter. Don't respond to the charge of the 2003 positive test by saying "You'll have to talk to the union." If you were going to be consistent with past statements, you should have replied "I've never used any performance-enhancing substance. If there is a positive test that is associated with my name, you will have to talk to the union or to Major League Baseball." Alex, you either have used or you haven't used a performance-enhancing substance during your time in professional baseball. Whatever the case may be, state it in your own words and state it so that everyone understands.
The tests in 2003 were supposed to be confidential in every manner and the results carried no punishment. You and every player involved has every right to be upset that some of the results have apparently been made public. That wasn't part of the deal, but don't attempt to use this issue as any sort of a shield. The union and MLB can battle on how the tests in 2003 were handled. That is their point to debate. Don't let yourself be a part of any cross-fire.
If you choose not to step forward and address these charges, you will travel the road of Mark McGwire and move in the opposite direction of your ultimate goal of the Hall of Fame. If you make a statement that comes under suspicion, you might find yourself in the company of Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens. It's true you won't be making your statement in front of a grand jury or a Congressional panel, but you will be making your statement before the Court of Public Opinion. The sentence for failing to tell the truth is unforgiving in all of these cases. You can start your meeting with the news media by stating, "Look, I'm going to tell you everything I know about any and all charges that I have used performance-enhancing substances. When I'm finished, you can ask me any questions you care to about the charges as they relate to me." I suppose it could turn out to be a rough session, Alex, but you can put this chapter of your career behind you and move on. In doing so, you would help the sport itself move past what has become known as the "Steroid Era."
You are a star player and you have a lot of years to play. You want to be looked upon as someone who was not only a great player but as someone who was willing to step forward when many hid behind a curtain. You won't need an agent or a team of lawyers standing beside you. This is about you and about the fans who care about the game.
A tricky ground ball is headed your way, Alex. Make the right play.
Sincerely,
Fred Claire